Reading and checking work well today. An assistant connected to one of the analysis servers can list every part on a sheet, pull the netlist, trace which pins share a net, run ERC and DRC, and explain the results in plain language. That helps most on a board you inherited, or as a second pair of eyes before a design review.
Editing is newer and rougher. Seeed's README says its schematic editing is experimental, that wire connections may not form perfect electrical connections, and that KiCad must be closed and reopened to see file changes. It recommends the KiCad GUI for design work. The kicad-mcp-python README says schematic support is still being developed, because it waits on KiCad's own schematic APIs. mixelpixx goes furthest (schematic editing, placement, routing through Freerouting, exports) and still carries a warning that AI suggestions do not replace qualified engineering review.
The kicad-mcp-pro README is worth reading even if you pick another server. Its signal-integrity, power-integrity, EMC and thermal tools are, in its own words, first-order closed-form estimates of roughly 5 to 10% accuracy and not a substitute for a field solver, and it calls itself an engineering assistant, not an autonomous manufacturing sign-off authority. We think that is the right way to treat all five.